She thought she could make it work, but just after moving in with Mueller, the situation worsened. Often quiet and reserved, he seemed like the exact opposite of what Carrie would have wanted out of a man.
Her friends say Muller seemed like a nice quiet guy, but he wasn't as much fun to be around. It was shortly after the breakup that she began dating Justine Mueller. But, Tim McVay made it very clear that he was not looking to be a father for the third time, which dashed Carrie Olson's hopes of making a family with him. Carrie Olson was ready to marry and spend the rest of her life with him. First, Tim McVay was divorced and was the father of two children. And with Carrie's bubbly and friendly personality, the two seemed like the perfect couple, at first.īut,there were some issues.
It was that magnetic personality that first drew Carrie to Tim, plus she thought he was incredibly cute. Her live-in-boyfriend, Justin Mueller, was finally cleared after months of gossip, according to Iowa Cold Cases.Īlways entertaining and dancing with the customers, he seemed to be a natural as he lead karaoke in the bars and saloons around town. Olson's ex-boyfriend, Tim McVay, was arrested and found guilty in her death. Her body, which was identified by a tattoo, had apparently been there since she disappeared but was hidden under the snow. The 29-year old woman was missing for months before her body was found in a heavily wooded area in Minnesota in April 2014. Carrie Olson's story began in December 2013, when she vanished from her Davenport, Iowa, home. The Carrie Elaine Olson, Tim (Timothy) McVay karaoke murder case will be profiled on the next Dateline NBC.